Red Hill Knives

Knife Set

What is the best brand to go with when buying a knife block set to use at home?

I’m thinking of purchasing a Stanley Rogers set, and also considering Wiltshire (Staysharp in particular). Would anyone recommend avoiding these?

I’d recommend reading this article on how to choose kitchen knives – http://zknives.com/knives/kitchen/misc/articles/kkchoser/index.shtml

It’d be better if you stay away from both brands you listed, and Cutco and Furi as well.

In general avoid any kitchen knife manufacturer that doesn’t state clearly the steel used in the knife. Vague statements like “quality stainless steel” or “surgical stainless steel” are as usual the lowest grade. The only exception being very high end knives, but then you’d know by price,

Second, avoid buying a set. Doesn’t matter how good it looks and how attractive the price is, you will get more than one knife in it that you do not need. You can get much better knives individually and still save money compared to the set.

I’ve had bunch of Globals in the past,(reviews here http://zknives.com/knives/kitchen/ktknv/indexbymk.shtml?Global ) before upgrading to better knives, but I still keep couple of them, they’re pretty good knives, but no point in buying the set.

As for the Wusthof, it’s ok, but definitely neither the best nor the Ferrari of knives. I am sharpening all the Henckels and Wusthofs my friends own, plus their and my own Globals too. Globals do hold better edge compared to both, Wusthof and Henckel.

Kitchen knives are judged by their cutting ability(mostly) and by that criteria western knives are nowhere near Japanese knives.
Edge angle on German and western knives is 45-50 degrees on average. That’s pretty good for an axe or combat knife that you plan chop trees and cables with, but too much for a kitchen knife.

Japanese knives are sharpened to much more acute angle, 30 or so. Therefore, they CUT a lot better. Also, because Japanese knives are thin they weigh less and cause less repetitive stress and exhaustion.

Japanese knives are harder compared to western knives – 54-58HRC on western knives and 58-67HRC on Japanese.
Harder knives hold edge longer and need less sharpening.
I don’t dismiss western knives altogether, they’re still good for those who don’t really want to spend time maintaining their knives and sharpening them. Because they’re so thick they take abuse better compared to Japanese blades.

Since it was mentioned already, avoid marketing BS or common knife myths. A good kitchen knife doesn’t need neither bolster, nor full tang, nor it needs to be forged.

Stamped Globals out-cut drop forged Wusthofs anytime.

Full tang was introduced back in early 20th century to automate cheap knife production, and contrary to the few thousand years of knifemaking it(full tang) is promoted today as something necessary.
Simple fact – neither katana swords nor Bowie knives have “full tang for strength”, yet those blades cut through armor, leather, bones and whatever else. So, think yourself, what you could possibly do in your kitchen more harsh than that?

Forged – The whole thing is based on forged is batter than stamped myth. It’s true, generally forged knife will be better, because nobody will spend time and money to forge crappy knife, but it isn’t necessary to make a good knife. The same Globals are excellent example. Most of them aren’t forged and cut a lot better than bunch of forged blades.
Besides, in today’s knifemaking factories no blade is truly forged. So, don’t expect artisan hammering your knife out of hot billet of steel. They’re cut with lasers and then drop forged by machines.

I have no idea who Emerald Green is, but TV shows and Magazines in general will promote ANY knife or brand as long as they pay the advertisement or sponsor something.
Same is true for most of the celebrity chefs. 95% of the time the knives they use on their shows is made by their sponsors or show sponsors, which has absolutely nothing to do with their real world performance.

Whetstone Cutlery™ Stripeger Kunai 12 Throwing knives Set $44.99

Whetstone Cutlery™ Ninjas Dozen Kunai 12 thowing knives set $44.99

NEW 6 PC TACTICAL METAL COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET Naruto KUNAI The Expendables $0.99

Vintage Zippo Doral Across America Knife Set W/ Original Case and Box $11.57

4.75" 3 PC MINI NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET SHEATH Naruto Military $0.01

Hunting Knife Set Letter Opener Set 2 Pc Free Shipping $9.95

5.5" 3 PC NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET + SHEATH Naruto Military Hunting $0.01

NEW 6 PC TACTICAL COMBAT METAL THROWING KNIFE SET Naruto KUNAI The Expendables $0.01

2PC SGIAN DUBH SET knife 210928 $19.95

unused Schrade 3 Stag handle knife set IXL with cases $525.00

Outdoor Life Ducks Unlimited DU Bird Knife Small Game Fish & Fowl Set $6.99

KNIVES-MOORE MAKER COMBO TRAPPER SET 1LRG. 1SM. FATHER & SON KNIFE SET U.S.A. TX $113.75

6" 3 PC NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET w/ SHEATH Naruto Military Hunting $0.01

6.5" 3 PC JACK THE RIPPER TITANIUM THROWING KNIFE SET Tactical Military Combat $0.01

SET OF 6 SPIDER NINJA THROWING KNIVES MADE IN PAKISTAN 5640-9 $0.99

RARE VINTAGE BUCK 501 100TH ANNIVERSARY FOLDING KNIFE SET SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED $74.99

PAPER MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL for KNIVES KNIFE 1/4" BLACK SET OF 2 $7.00

NEW 6 PC COMBAT TACTICAL METAL THROWING KNIFE SET Naruto KUNAI The Expendables $0.99

PAPER MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL for KNIVES KNIFE 3/16" BROWN SET OF 2 $7.00

VINTAGE SHEFFIELD KNIFE CARVING SET, ENGLAND $5.50

NEW 7" SET OF 6 BLACK NINJA THROWING KNIFE VELCRO SHEATH TR0487-16 $4.95

G-10 MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL for KNIVES KNIFE 3/8" RED SET OF 2 $13.00

G-10 MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL KNIVES KNIFE 1/8" IVORY COLOR/GREY SET OF 2 $8.50

Cord Wrapped Survival Knife & Fire Starter Set In/Sheath Hunting Bushcraft Fish $4.25

Smith & Wesson Special Ops Tactical Pocket Knife and Watch Gift Set - New $49.73

5.5" 3 PC NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET + SHEATH Naruto Hunting Military $0.01

G-10 MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL for KNIVES KNIFE 1/4" IVORY COLOR SET OF 2 $15.00

Frost Cutlery Wildlife Set of 4 Folding Knives Eagle Bear Wolf & Deer $0.01

G-10 MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL for KNIVES KNIFE 1/2" IVORY COLOR SET OF 2 $20.00

6.5" 3 PC KUNAI NINJA COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET w/SHEATH Naruto Military Hunting $0.01

6.5" 3 PC JACK THE RIPPER TITANIUM THROWING KNIFE SET Tactical Combat Military $0.01

Case 2004 Encyclopedia Set Single Blade Doctors Knife - 1 of 350 $79.00

NEW 6 PC TACTICAL METAL COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET Naruto KUNAI The Expendables $0.99

G-10 MICARTA SCALES HANDLE MATERIAL KNIVES KNIFE 1/8" YELLOWISH BROWN SET OF 2 $7.00

Miniature 2pc set Letter Survival Knives VIII941-GHK $8.99

Queen Steel Wood Handles Full Tang Knives Carving Set,With Wood Display $24.50

4.75" 3 PC MINI NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET SHEATH Naruto Military $0.01

LOU GEHRIG "THE IRON HORSE" LIMITED EDITION CASE KNIFE & STAMP SET $42.66

5.5" 3 PC NINJA KUNAI COMBAT THROWING KNIFE SET + SHEATH Naruto Military Hunting $0.01

Case 1989 Centennial Mint Set Toothpick Knife Long Tail C Serial #029 Mint NR $86.00